The term “subculture” has become a ubiquitous term in cultural studies, often used to describe a group within a larger society that shares distinct values, beliefs, practices, and styles that differentiate them from the dominant culture. This essay delves into the multifaceted concept of subculture, exploring its historical development, theoretical perspectives, and methodologies used to study it. It will draw extensively on the works of prominent cultural critics and theorists who have shaped our understanding of subcultures. Furthermore, the essay will examine specific examples of Indian cultural artefacts and analyze how they have been defined and analyzed as subcultures by cultural critics.
Defining Subculture
The Oxford English Dictionary defines subculture as “an identifiable subgroup within a society or group of people, especially one characterized by beliefs or interests at variance with those of the larger group; the distinctive ideas, practices, or way of life of such a subgroup.” 1 This definition highlights the inherent tension between a subculture and the dominant culture, suggesting a divergence in values, beliefs, and practices.
Early definitions of subculture often focused on its perceived deviance from societal norms. Dick Hebdige, in his influential work Subculture: The Meaning of Style, argued that subcultures emerge as a form of subversion and resistance against the dominant culture1. He wrote that subcultures can be perceived as negative due to their nature of criticism to the dominant societal standard1. He saw subcultures as a way for individuals, particularly youth, to express their dissatisfaction with societal standards and create their own identity1.
However, more contemporary perspectives on subculture have moved beyond the notion of deviance and resistance. Sarah Thornton, for instance, proposes the concept of “taste cultures,” suggesting that subcultures are characterized by shared tastes and preferences, forming fluid and porous boundaries with the mainstream culture1. This perspective emphasizes the dynamic and evolving nature of subcultures, acknowledging their interaction and integration with the broader cultural landscape. Thornton suggests that subcultures demonstrate an underground taste, with regard to mass culture, in order to increase their own status2.
Historical Development of the Concept
The concept of subculture emerged in the early 20th century, with roots in the Chicago School of sociology3. Initially, subcultures were studied as forms of deviance and delinquency, often associated with marginalized groups and criminal behavior1. The Chicago School scholars, influenced by Durkheim’s sociology, examined how subcultures arose in urban environments due to social disorganization and the lack of integration with mainstream society2. Robert Park, Ernest Burgess, and Louis Wirth, key figures of the Chicago School, suggested that through processes of selection and segregation, “natural areas” or “moral regions” appear in society where individuals with deviant behaviors concentrate and reinforce alternative axiological and normative models1.
In the post-World War II era, the focus shifted towards understanding subcultures as expressions of resistance and social opposition1. The Birmingham Centre for Contemporary Cultural Studies (CCCS), led by scholars like Stuart Hall and Dick Hebdige, played a pivotal role in this shift1. They drew on Gramsci’s theory of hegemony to analyze how subcultures, particularly youth subcultures, challenged the dominant ideology through their distinctive styles and practices2.
From the 1980s onwards, subcultural studies further evolved, incorporating postmodern perspectives and recognizing the fluidity and fragmentation of subcultural identities2. The rise of youth cultures associated with music genres like punk, goth, and hip hop, as well as the emergence of online communities and virtual subcultures, led to new interpretations and methodologies for studying subcultures1. The increasing use of social media, including the internet, virtual reality, and online games, has been identified as a significant factor in the emergence and development of new subcultures, particularly among young people3.
Theoretical Perspectives on Subculture
Several theoretical perspectives have been employed to understand subcultures, each offering unique insights into their formation, dynamics, and impact on society.
Functionalism: This perspective views subcultures as serving a function within society by providing a sense of belonging and identity to individuals who feel marginalized or alienated from the mainstream culture5. Functionalists argue that subcultures can act as a safety valve, allowing individuals to express their discontent and negotiate their identity without completely rejecting societal norms. For example, the goth subculture (characterised by a dark aesthetic, love of Gothic literature, and interest in horror films), with its characteristic dark clothing, music, and aesthetic, provides a sense of community and belonging to individuals who feel alienated from mainstream society’s emphasis on optimism and conformity.
Symbolic Interactionism: This perspective emphasizes the role of shared meanings and symbols in the creation and maintenance of subcultures5. Symbolic interactionists focus on how individuals within a subculture interact and communicate, constructing their identity through shared rituals, language, and styles. For instance, within the skateboarding subculture, specific terms, tricks, and styles of riding convey shared meanings and create a sense of identity among its members.
Conflict Theory: This perspective views subcultures as a reflection of social inequalities and power struggles within society6. Conflict theorists argue that subcultures emerge as a response to social and economic marginalization, and their resistance to the dominant culture can be seen as a form of class struggle. For example, the punk subculture, with its anti-establishment ideology and rebellious attitude, can be seen as a reaction to social and economic inequalities experienced by working-class youth.
Postmodernism: This perspective challenges the traditional notions of fixed and stable subcultural identities7. Postmodernists argue that subcultures are fluid, fragmented, and constantly evolving, influenced by globalization, media, and consumer culture. They emphasize the hybridity and individual agency in shaping subcultural identities. For instance, the hipster subculture, with its eclectic mix of styles, music, and interests, reflects the postmodern emphasis on individuality, hybridity, and the blurring of boundaries between subcultures and mainstream culture.
Cultural Critics on Subculture
Cultural critics have played a crucial role in shaping our understanding of subcultures, offering diverse perspectives and insights. Here are some notable quotes and arguments:
- Dick Hebdige: “A subculture is a subversion to normalcy. Subcultures frequently have a bad reputation and a critical mindset. Subcultures unite people who feel ignored and give them a place to find their identities.” 8
- Peter J. Carroll: “Ideas about a person’s place in society, his role, lifestyle, and ego qualities will lose their hold as the cohesive forces in society disintegrate. Subculture values will proliferate to such a bewildering extent that a whole new class of professionals will arise to control them.” 9
- Andy Crouch: “If there is a constructive way forward for Christians in the midst of our broken but also beautiful cultures, it will require us to recover these two biblical postures of cultivation and creation.” 10
- Thom Yorke: “I would dream. I focused all my attention on going to America. The subculture, James Dean, the rock n’ roll, the beat writers.” 11
These quotes highlight the diverse perspectives on subcultures, ranging from their role in resistance and identity formation to their potential impact on social structures and cultural values.
Methodologies for Studying Subcultures
Various methodologies have been employed to study subcultures, often drawing on interdisciplinary approaches.
Ethnography: This involves immersing oneself in the subculture, observing and participating in its activities, and conducting interviews with its members12. Ethnographic studies provide rich and detailed accounts of subcultural life, capturing its nuances and complexities.
Semiotic Analysis: This involves analyzing the symbols, language, and styles used by a subculture to understand its meanings and values12. Semiotic analysis helps decipher the ways in which subcultures communicate their identity and differentiate themselves from the mainstream culture.
Content Analysis: This involves analyzing cultural artefacts produced by a subculture, such as music, fashion, and online content, to understand its themes, values, and ideologies13. Content analysis provides insights into the cultural production and consumption patterns within a subculture.
Participant Observation: This involves actively participating in the activities of a subculture while observing and documenting its practices and interactions13. Participant observation allows researchers to gain firsthand experience and build rapport with subcultural members, leading to a deeper understanding of their lived experiences. When conducting participant observation, it is crucial to be mindful of ethical considerations, such as obtaining informed consent, maintaining confidentiality, and avoiding any harm to the community being studied13. Researchers should also be aware of their own biases and strive to maintain objectivity while immersing themselves in the subculture13.
Indian Subcultures: Examples and Analysis
India, with its diverse cultural landscape, offers a rich tapestry of subcultures. These subcultures are often defined by factors such as religion, caste, ethnicity, region, language, and shared interests14.
Religious Subcultures
India is home to numerous religious communities, each with its own distinct beliefs, practices, and traditions. Hinduism, Islam, Sikhism, Christianity, Buddhism, and Jainism are some of the major religions that have shaped Indian society. Each of these religions can be seen as a subculture within the larger Indian context, with its own unique set of values, rituals, and social norms15. For example, Hinduism encompasses a vast array of beliefs, practices, and sub-traditions, including various schools of thought, devotional practices, and regional variations.
Within Hinduism, specific practices and rituals can also be viewed as subcultural expressions. For instance, “Pradakshina,” the ritualistic circumambulation (the act of walking around a sacred object or idol, usually as a ritual or formal procession) of sacred spaces such as temples and shrines, is a unique cultural practice that can be considered a subcultural element within Hinduism16. This practice symbolizes the devotee’s reverence and devotion to the deity and reinforces the sacredness of the space.
Furthermore, the “subtleties of Indian culture” discussed in 16 contribute to the diversity of Indian subcultures. These subtleties include concepts like “Arati,” a ritual of offering light to a deity, and “Death by Demand,” a controversial practice of voluntary death in certain religious contexts. These practices, while not universally accepted, reflect the diverse beliefs and values within Indian society.
Caste-Based Subcultures
The caste system, though officially abolished, continues to influence social structures and identities in India17. Different castes have their own distinct customs, occupations, and social hierarchies, forming subcultures within the broader Indian society. Cultural critics have analyzed how caste-based subcultures perpetuate social inequalities and discrimination, while also providing a sense of community and identity to their members18.
The tension between subcultures and the dominant culture is particularly evident in the context of caste-based subcultures. While the dominant culture promotes equality and social mobility, the persistence of caste-based discrimination and social hierarchies creates a conflict between these ideals and the lived realities of many Indians. This tension manifests in various forms, such as social exclusion, limited access to resources, and the perpetuation of traditional occupations based on caste.
Tribal Subcultures
India has a significant tribal population, with diverse indigenous communities residing in different parts of the country. These tribal groups have their own unique languages, customs, and belief systems, forming distinct subcultures within the larger Indian society. Cultural critics have examined how tribal subcultures have been marginalized and impacted by modernization, while also highlighting their resilience and cultural richness18.
Youth Subcultures
With a large youth population, India has witnessed the emergence of various youth subcultures, often influenced by global trends and media. These subcultures are characterized by their distinctive styles, music preferences, and social attitudes. Cultural critics have analyzed how Indian youth subcultures negotiate their identity in a rapidly changing society, grappling with issues of globalization, consumerism, and tradition19.
Globalization has had a significant impact on youth subcultures in India, leading to the adoption of Western trends, consumerism, and the emergence of new forms of cultural expression19. For example, the increasing popularity of Western music, fashion, and social media platforms among Indian youth reflects the influence of globalization on their cultural preferences and identity formation.
Examples of Indian Subcultures Analyzed by Cultural Critics
| Subculture | Defining Characteristics | Cultural Critics’ Analysis |
|---|---|---|
| Hijras | Transgender community with distinct social structure, rituals, and beliefs. | Navigate social stigma and discrimination while maintaining resilience and cultural contributions20. |
| Indie Music Scene | Challenges the mainstream Bollywood music industry by fostering creativity and promoting alternative music genres. | Provides a platform for independent artists and contributes to the diversity of Indian music21. |
| Street Art and Graffiti | Expresses social and political commentary through visual art forms in public spaces. | Challenges conventional notions of art and reflects urban realities and social issues22. |
Family Structure and Cultural Norms
The traditional Indian family structure, often characterized by joint families and arranged marriages, has been undergoing significant changes due to modernization and globalization23. The rise of nuclear families and the increasing prevalence of love marriages reflect the evolving cultural norms and subcultural variations within Indian society.
Arranged marriages, while still common, are increasingly incorporating elements of consent and choice23. Dowry and inheritance laws, though legally reformed, continue to be influenced by traditional practices and cultural norms23. These practices reflect the complex interplay between tradition and modernity in shaping family structures and subcultural dynamics in India.
Conclusion
The concept of subculture remains a dynamic and evolving area of study in cultural studies. From its early focus on deviance to its contemporary understanding as fluid and multifaceted expressions of identity, subcultures continue to offer valuable insights into the complexities of human societies. The Indian context, with its rich cultural diversity, provides a fertile ground for exploring the various forms and dynamics of subcultures. By examining specific examples and drawing on the works of prominent cultural critics, we can gain a deeper understanding of how subcultures shape individual identities, challenge societal norms, and contribute to the ever-changing cultural landscape of India.
However, it is important to acknowledge the challenges and complexities of defining and studying subcultures in the Indian context. As cultural critic S.N. Balagangadhara argues, applying Western theoretical frameworks to Indian subcultures can be limiting and may not fully capture the nuances of indigenous cultural practices and social dynamics25. There is a need for more culturally specific approaches that take into account the unique historical, social, and religious contexts of Indian subcultures.
Furthermore, the concept of culture itself in the Indian context is deeply intertwined with religion, spirituality, and traditional knowledge systems26. This necessitates a more nuanced understanding of subcultures that goes beyond Western notions of deviance and resistance, and considers the intricate relationship between subcultures and the broader cultural paradigms within Indian society.
Works cited
1. Subculture – Wikipedia, accessed on January 30, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Subculture
2. Subcultures. State of the Art and Future Perspectives in Sociology | Roma TrE-Press, accessed on January 30, 2025, https://romatrepress.uniroma3.it/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/Subcultures.-State-of-the-Art-and-Future-Perspectives-in-Sociology.pdf
3. 2019-ardila-subcultural-theory-.pdf, accessed on January 30, 2025, https://aalfredoardila.files.wordpress.com/2019/10/2019-ardila-subcultural-theory-.pdf
4. Subculture theory: An historical and contemporary assessment of the concept for understanding deviance, accessed on January 30, 2025, https://typeset.io/pdf/subculture-theory-an-historical-and-contemporary-assessment-3y3aemhyq1.pdf
5. Subcultures: The Basics – Easy Sociology, accessed on January 30, 2025, https://easysociology.com/sociology-of-culture/sociology-of-subculture/subcultures-the-basics/
6. Subcultural Theories of Deviance – Simply Psychology, accessed on January 30, 2025, https://www.simplypsychology.org/subcultural-theories-crime-deviance.html
7. Still ‘Winning Space?’: Updating Subcultural Theory – University of Rochester, accessed on January 30, 2025, https://www.rochester.edu/in_visible_culture/issue2/IVC-Subcultures/Geoff_Stahl.html
8. Ask the Sociologist: Unsure about Subcultures, accessed on January 30, 2025, https://thesociologistdc.com/all-issues/ask-the-sociologist-unsure-about-subcultures/
9. Subculture Quotes – Creatosaurus, accessed on January 30, 2025, https://www.creatosaurus.io/apps/quotes/topics/subculture-quotes
10. Culture Making Quotes by Andy Crouch – Goodreads, accessed on January 30, 2025, https://www.goodreads.com/work/quotes/3094100-culture-making-recovering-our-creative-calling
11. Subculture Quotes – BrainyQuote, accessed on January 30, 2025, https://www.brainyquote.com/topics/subculture-quotes
12. Introduction – University of Rochester, accessed on January 30, 2025, https://www.rochester.edu/in_visible_culture/issue2/introduction.htm
13. Studying Subcultures using Participant Observation – Everyday Sociology Blog, accessed on January 30, 2025, https://www.everydaysociologyblog.com/2009/05/studying-subcultures-using-participant-observation.html
14. Indian Culture and Its Distinctive Qualities | Free Paper Example for Students – Aithor, accessed on January 30, 2025, https://aithor.com/essay-examples/indian-culture-and-its-distinctive-qualities
15. Hinduism and Indian Culture | ONE Magazine – CNEWA, accessed on January 30, 2025, https://cnewa.org/magazine/hinduism-and-indian-culture-30693/
16. India’s Subcultures – Kamat’s Potpourri, accessed on January 30, 2025, https://kamat.com/indica/culture/sub-cultures/
17. Through the Prism of Culture: Evaluating LLMs’ Understanding of Indian Subcultures and Traditions – arXiv, accessed on January 30, 2025, https://arxiv.org/html/2501.16748v1
18. Navigating the Culture of Critique – Futuress, accessed on January 30, 2025, https://futuress.org/stories/culture-of-critique/
19. East-Indian Culture and Subcultures | Free Essay Example – StudyCorgi, accessed on January 30, 2025, https://studycorgi.com/east-indian-culture-and-subcultures/
20. Hijras: the unique transgender culture of India – Taylor & Francis Online, accessed on January 30, 2025, https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/17542863.2011.570915
21. 16 books to celebrate South Asian Heritage Month – Bloomsbury Publishing, accessed on January 30, 2025, https://www.bloomsbury.com/uk/discover/articles/book-round-ups/16-books-to-celebrate-south-asian-heritage-month/
22. Researching Subcultures, Inc. | The New School for Social Research, accessed on January 30, 2025, https://www.newschool.edu/nssr/story/researching-subcultures-inc/
23. Culture of India – Wikipedia, accessed on January 30, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Culture_of_India
24. Indian family systems, collectivistic society and psychotherapy – PMC, accessed on January 30, 2025, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3705700/
25. A review summary of Cultures Differ Differently: Selected Essays of S.N. Balagangadhara, accessed on January 30, 2025, https://pragyata.com/a-review-summary-of-cultures-differ-differently-selected-essays-of-s-n-balagangadhara/
26. The Culture Iceberg – A Discussion and Critique, accessed on January 30, 2025, https://www.brhat.in/dhiti/cultureiceberg
Literary Latitude 